| Getting
God's Ear Sermon by Cynthia A. Jarvis October 13, 2002, Presbyterian Church of Chestnut Hill Isaiah 1:7-20 "When you stretch out your hands, I will hide my eyes from you; even though you make many prayers, I will not listen." Sunday morning is the time and a church's sanctuary is the place people gather to get God's ear. We come with our accumulated woes, with our tangible thanksgivings, with our confessions of the good we have left undone and the wrong we have done, begging God's pardon. And we come with our griefs, uncovering them that they might "prove to be but one sole common grief…beweeping them and crying aloud to the heavens and calling upon God," says Miguel Unamuno. "And this, even though God should hear us not; but he would hear us. The chiefest sanctity of a temple," we have said so many times of this temple, "is that it is a place to which [we] go to weep in common. A Miserere sung in common by a multitude tormented by destiny…." We are such a multitude this morning, some tormented
by a destiny near at hand in a doctor's word, a job's end, a family's
broken pieces…many tormented by a destiny now become randomly vulnerable
to a sniper's aim at all things ordinary…each of us tormented by a national
destiny thrust upon us in the night and now, theoretically, held in
the hands of a single human being. With these griefs, these confessions,
these thanksgivings, these woes, we have gathered, as we do every Sunday
morning, to get God's ear on behalf of our lives and in the face of
our deaths. It goes without saying that we are not the first generation
to do this. Week after week in these holy pages, we listen in on the
conversation of those who have gone before us, who have--successfully
or unsuccessfully--addressed the Almighty in times of war and peace,
well-being and hardship, defeat and victory. Wanting to be a part of
that conversation now, we turn to the church, to the institution that
has presumed to know how God's ear can be had, to the body that has
routinized the way in which people are to call upon God, generation
after generation. Of that routinized conversation as it is recorded
in our texts this morning, we may say, on one hand, that such routine
breeds confidence in those of us who would call upon God in time of
need. "The higher Christian churches," writes Annie Dillard, "come at
God with an unwarranted air of professionalism, with authority and pomp,
as though they knew what they were doing, as though people in themselves
were an appropriate set of creatures to have dealings with God. I often
think of the set pieces of liturgy as certain words which people have
successfully addressed to God without their getting killed." Therefore,
prayed the Pharisee with confidence, "God, I thank you that I am not
like other people, thieves, rogues, adulterers, or even like this tax
collector. I fast twice a week, I give a tenth of all my income." I
have the routine down, O God: hear my prayer! Yet there is also
the possibility that the routine words we use to get God's attention
have not only numbed us to the majesty and mystery and so to the reality
of the living God, but in the changed circumstances of our world, have
caused God to grow angry against our prayers, according to the psalmist,
have made God burdened and weary in the midst of our assemblies, says
Isaiah to the people of Judah. We cannot know for sure the historical
details of Isaiah's first chapter, wherein God chooses not to listen.
A good guess is that the time is post-701 B.C. Intelligent leadership
in the person of King Hezekiah is gone from the land. In the years following
his death, the nation of Judah reaches its nadir: righteousness succumbs
to blood-letting, justice gives way to bribery, silver becomes dross.
Though God has preserved a faithful remnant, their voices cannot be
heard over the voice of God's "sustained indictment against a nation
that has lost its bearings," says Christopher Seitz, "against a leadership
that ignores basic acts of justice and simple-not elaborate-acts of
contrition and obedience." Though disturbingly, God's anger in Isaiah's
first chapter burns not against the leaders of the nation but, in the
face of a nation unbearably lost, against those who worship as they
have always worshipped, pray as they have always prayed, maintain the
routine of their religion as though God were in heaven and all was right
with the world. "I cannot endure solemn assemblies with iniquity," says
the Lord. "Your new moons and your appointed festivals, my soul hates;
they have become a burden to me, I am weary of bearing them." Therefore
says God to the congregation, "When you stretch out your hands, I will
hide my eyes from you; even though you make many prayers, I will not
listen; your hands are full of blood." Given the changed social
context, the places of Judah's worship have now become places "of self-indulgence
and satiation," says Walter Brueggemann of our text. "Yahweh has become
a function of a religious enterprise that is manipulative and self-satisfying,
but that has completely forfeited any reference to the sovereign God…Whereas
the cult was authorized to be a vehicle for the unlikely practice of
communion with Yahweh," he concludes, "it has now become a place where
the reality of Yahweh, in Yahweh's true character, is almost completely
disregarded and forfeited." Yet why would this be? After all these
years of abiding their solemn assemblies and appointed festivals, why
would God now turn away, angered by their prayers? We can only surmise
that, in the time of Hezekiah, when the common order was an order that
provided for the widow and the orphan, rescued the oppressed and sought
justice in the land, then the routine of worship and the ritual of prayer
did no harm. But now the common life has no place for the least of these,
making routinized prayer into complicity with injustice and worship
into an affront against God's word. Now enter the prophet, who speaks
not in prose, but in poetry, who addresses "a culture competent to implement
anything and to imagine almost nothing," the prophet, whose vocation
it is to "keep alive the ministry of imagination," says Brueggemann,
"to keep on conjuring and proposing alternative futures to the single
one the king wants to urge as the only thinkable one." My friends,
the context of our praying has changed. More and more, these times feel
like a nadir, of sorts, in this nation's history. There is, of course,
the economy, stupid, and the consequences of its decline felt most deeply
by the vulnerable in our society: the working poor, single parent households,
the elderly, the ill facing a crumbling medical establishment. There
is the cacophony of war's alarm sounding all around and rousing us to
assert military might against international snipers we can no more catch
than we seem able to find the ones stalking the perimeter of our nation's
capital. But more to the point of getting or losing God's ear, there
are voices across the land claiming God's imprimatur as though we were
completely good and the other completely evil, as though, in the words
ofi the New Yorker's Hendrik Hertsberg, "we are exempt from fallen
human nature and stand outside history…" as though, "if the other side
is absolutely evil then we must be absolutely good, so it's fine for
us to be absolutely powerful." To the arrogance of such power and
such presumption, to those whose prayers begin, "Thank God I am not
like the other people-thieves, rogues, adulterers," the God of the biblical
witness does not listen, but rather retorts, "remove the evil of your
doings before my eyes; cease to do evil, learn to do good, seek justice,
rescue the oppressed, defend the orphan, plead for the widow." It is
what many have been led to believe we are doing by the prose
of politicians and pollsters. It may even be what is intended in the
halls of power as we rattle our sabers and seek to secure our borders.
Why should we not pray God's blessing upon this crusade to rid the world
of evil? The answer offered by the One whose parable would teach
us to pray is an answer that turns our prayers on God's deaf ear! The
point of the parable we think we know so well: that God prefers humility
to arrogance when we pray. What we miss is the sharp edge of Jesus'
words to those who were humbly certain that their words and actions
and so their prayers were justified in God's hearing and beyond the
reproach of God's anger. I felt that edge, this week, as I happened
upon Mark Twain's very short story, "The War Prayer," and heard, in
his midrash on Psalm 80 and Jesus' parable, the sharp edge of God's
anger against our prayers. Written in 1905 during the American occupation
of the Philippines, the story went unpublished until 1923 because the
editors "thought it unsuitable for publication at a moment of high and
patriotic feeling." The story begins: "It was a time of great and exalting
excitement. The country was swept up in arms…in every breast burned
the holy fire of patriotism…On every hand and far down the receding
and fading spread of roofs and balconies a fluttering wilderness of
flags flashed in the sun…Sunday morning came…the church was filled…The
service proceeded; a war chapter from the Old Testament was read…Then
came the 'long' prayer…The burden of its supplication was that an ever
merciful…Father of us all would watch over our noble young soldiers…help
them to crush the foe, grant to them and to their flag and country imperishable
honor and glory." While the minister prayed fervently, an aged stranger
walked up the aisle. At the prayer's conclusion, the stranger motioned
the minister aside and began to address the congregation. "I come from
the Throne-bearing a message from Almighty God…He has heard the prayer
of His servant your shepherd…For it is like unto many of the prayers
of men, in that it asks for more than he who utters it is aware of-except
he pause and think." The stranger then speaks the prayer that God's
ear hears beneath the prayer spoken by the minister,
|